The Ouse Valley Benefice

Paying Taxes to Caesar

Picture the scene: Holy Week in Jerusalem, tension thick enough to cut with a knife. Jesus walks right into a carefully orchestrated trap set by two bitter ideological enemies - the Pharisees and the Herodians. Normally, these groups wouldn't be found in the same room. The Pharisees were fiercely nationalistic and detested paying taxes to Rome; the Herodians were political insiders who cozied up to the empire. But common hatred brings strange bedfellows together, and they unite with one goal: to back Jesus into an impossible corner.

With slick flattery, they ask the question: "Is it right to pay the poll-tax to Caesar or not?" It is a masterpiece of a trap. Say yes, and Jesus is branded a traitor to God’s people. Say no, and he is dragged before the Roman governor for rebellion. Heads they win, tails Jesus loses.

But Jesus doesn’t panic. Asking for a coin, he points to the Emperor Tiberius’s stamp and delivers that brilliant, paradigm-shifting punchline: "Give back to Caesar what is Caesar’s, and to God what is God’s."

On the surface, he acknowledges basic civic responsibility. But he instantly lifts the conversation onto a higher plane. We live with a dual citizenship: we respect the laws of the land, but we also belong to our creator. Caesar can claim a piece of silver because his face is stamped on it. But what bears the image of God? We do.

Throughout the Bible, scripture reminds us that we are minted, stamped, and engraved with the image of God. His breath is breathed into us. Therefore, giving to God what is God's doesn’t mean carving our lives into neat little boxes. It doesn’t mean giving ourselves to God on a Sunday while keeping the rest for ourselves. It means offering our whole selves - our hearts, our time, and our love - back to the One who made us.

In a broken world, we are God's currency, and that currency is made up of love. Let us live each day as citizens of heaven, bringing his light and grace into every place we are planted.

Weekly Church of England Online Service

Do you know someone who is unable to get to church? 

If so, why not point them in the direction of the weekly online service from the Church of England. They can sign up to a weekly mailing with details of the service and watch each of the services online. Click the button below for more details and to sign up.